Welcome to Nunzio's Pizza
At Nunzio's Pizza, located in Scotch Plains, NJ, the passion for authentic Italian cuisine shines through. With a rich history spanning decades, this beloved spot has evolved while maintaining its commitment to quality. Diners rave about the diverse menu, featuring everything from gourmet white pizzas to specialty pies like the Brooklyn Square and unique options like the Cheesesteak pie. The warm, friendly atmosphere enhances the dining experience, making it a favorite for families and friends alike. With glowing reviews praising the delicious food and attentive service, Nunzio's Pizza is truly a gem for anyone craving mouthwatering pizza and comfort food.
- 2387 Mountain Ave, Scotch Plains, NJ 07076, United States Hotline: +1 908-889-4464
Welcome to Nunzio's Pizza, a beloved gem nestled in the heart of Scotch Plains, NJ, located at 2387 Mountain Ave. This restaurant has firmly established itself as a local favorite, offering not just exceptional pizza, but also a warm and welcoming atmosphere that keeps customers coming back for more. With a phone number of +1 908-889-4464, placing an order has never been easier.
Specializing in a variety of delicious pizzas, Nunzio's boasts a menu that caters to all tastes. Choose from their standout options, including:
- Meat Lovers Pizza - a carnivore's dream at $21.50
- Grandma Pizza - a classic take, also at $21.50
- Vegetarian Pizza - packed with fresh ingredients, priced at $21.50
- Nunzio's Pie - a unique creation for $21.50
- Brooklyn Square - a fan favorite for $21.50
- Sicilian Foccacia Style - another exceptional choice at $21.50
If you're in the mood for something a bit different, try their tantalizing white gourmet pizzas. Options like the Bianca ($15.50) and Four Cheese ($17.95) showcase a delightful array of flavors. Vegetarian selections like the Spinach and Tomato pizza ($17.95) are fresh and satisfying, making it difficult to choose just one!
But it’s not just the pizzas that stand out. With rave reviews like Daniel Veloza's praise for their buffalo wings and Don Earp's enthusiasm for the 'absolutely amazing' pizza, Nunzio's clearly excels in quality and taste. Patrons like Christine Racinez appreciate the consistency and family-friendly atmosphere that has been a cornerstone of the establishment for decades.
One of the highlights of Nunzio's is its commitment to using high-quality ingredients. As mentioned by loyal customers, the affordability of the menu items reflects the superior quality of the food served. Chris Shadis speaks to the reliability and friendliness of the staff, affirming that this is the perfect place to grab a quick bite or enjoy a family dinner.
If you’re in the area and craving a delicious meal, be sure to visit Nunzio's Pizza. Whether you're indulging in their signature pies or sampling their other offerings like tacos, you’re guaranteed a delightful dining experience that leaves you looking forward to your next visit.

Their Buffalo wings are pretty good.

I’ve had their food in the past and it was very very good. I ordered pizza tonight and it was absolutely amazing!!! Best pizza I’ve had in a long time. The restaurant is clean, the people are friendly and the food is excellent!!!

the best burger I have ever eaten

The food is soooooo good I can say it’s one of my favorite places to eat and ya’ll need to try the wings such a great flavor totally recommend!!!! EVERYTHING is absolutely delicious!! such a great Service too, and the people working there are always very friendly.

Favorite quick bite! Pizza delish

exploring the area got hingru and uhhh let me tell you great spot to come eat, food was delicious i did quesadillas and burger great prices

Our family has been going to Nunzio's for decades. We were skeptical about another new owner/management change if the pizza would change drastically. After 40 years, we have changed our usual family order to their Brooklyn pie. I don't think we have ever had an order that wasn't above excellent. Their pricing reflects the quality of ingredients, it's worth it. From a quick bite after getting off the 114 bus or for a nice family dinner, this is still my go-to pizza place.

Really nice people here. I've seen the place go through multiple owners and Staff before the current ones but they are really nice, good prices, and they have good snacks too like tacos or taquitos too. Very reliable place and always happy to order when I have friends in town visiting.